837 & 789 Main Street Andrews, NC - Image 1837 & 789 Main Street Andrews, NC - Image 2837 & 789 Main Street Andrews, NC - Image 3837 & 789 Main Street Andrews, NC - Image 4837 & 789 Main Street Andrews, NC - Image 5837 & 789 Main Street Andrews, NC - Image 6837 & 789 Main Street Andrews, NC - Image 7837 & 789 Main Street Andrews, NC - Image 8837 & 789 Main Street Andrews, NC - Image 9837 & 789 Main Street Andrews, NC - Image 10837 & 789 Main Street Andrews, NC - Image 11837 & 789 Main Street Andrews, NC - Image 12837 & 789 Main Street Andrews, NC - Image 13837 & 789 Main Street Andrews, NC - Image 14837 & 789 Main Street Andrews, NC - Image 15837 & 789 Main Street Andrews, NC - Image 16837 & 789 Main Street Andrews, NC - Image 17837 & 789 Main Street Andrews, NC - Image 18837 & 789 Main Street Andrews, NC - Image 19837 & 789 Main Street Andrews, NC - Image 20837 & 789 Main Street Andrews, NC - Image 21837 & 789 Main Street Andrews, NC - Image 22837 & 789 Main Street Andrews, NC - Image 23837 & 789 Main Street Andrews, NC - Image 24837 & 789 Main Street Andrews, NC - Image 25837 & 789 Main Street Andrews, NC - Image 26837 & 789 Main Street Andrews, NC - Image 27837 & 789 Main Street Andrews, NC - Image 28837 & 789 Main Street Andrews, NC - Image 29837 & 789 Main Street Andrews, NC - Image 30837 & 789 Main Street Andrews, NC - Image 31837 & 789 Main Street Andrews, NC - Image 32837 & 789 Main Street Andrews, NC - Image 33837 & 789 Main Street Andrews, NC - Image 34837 & 789 Main Street Andrews, NC - Image 35837 & 789 Main Street Andrews, NC - Image 36837 & 789 Main Street Andrews, NC - Image 37837 & 789 Main Street Andrews, NC - Image 38837 & 789 Main Street Andrews, NC - Image 39837 & 789 Main Street Andrews, NC - Image 40837 & 789 Main Street Andrews, NC - Image 41837 & 789 Main Street Andrews, NC - Image 42837 & 789 Main Street Andrews, NC - Image 43837 & 789 Main Street Andrews, NC - Image 44837 & 789 Main Street Andrews, NC - Image 45837 & 789 Main Street Andrews, NC - Image 46837 & 789 Main Street Andrews, NC - Image 47837 & 789 Main Street Andrews, NC - Image 48837 & 789 Main Street Andrews, NC - Image 49837 & 789 Main Street Andrews, NC - Image 50837 & 789 Main Street Andrews, NC - Image 51837 & 789 Main Street Andrews, NC - Image 52837 & 789 Main Street Andrews, NC - Image 53837 & 789 Main Street Andrews, NC - Image 54837 & 789 Main Street Andrews, NC - Image 55837 & 789 Main Street Andrews, NC - Image 56837 & 789 Main Street Andrews, NC - Image 57837 & 789 Main Street Andrews, NC - Image 58837 & 789 Main Street Andrews, NC - Image 59837 & 789 Main Street Andrews, NC - Image 60837 & 789 Main Street Andrews, NC - Image 61837 & 789 Main Street Andrews, NC - Image 62837 & 789 Main Street Andrews, NC - Image 63837 & 789 Main Street Andrews, NC - Image 64837 & 789 Main Street Andrews, NC - Image 65

$2,220,000

9 Beds 7 / 1 Full / Half Baths 2,578 SQFT 2.55 Acres
Type: Single Family

837 & 789 Main Street
Andrews, NC 28901

MLS#: 100608625
Brandyn Reagan
Brandyn Reagan
Bay Street Realty Group
Sales Associate
Phone: 912.335.9150
Office: 912.233.6000
Presented by: Allison Ralph with Nantahala Real Estate.

Property Description

 

Rare opportunity to acquire a true multi-generational / multi-use family compound occupying 2.55 acres in the heart of downtown Andrews, North Carolina. The parcel runs from Main Street through to Wilson Street, offering both prominent frontage and a private rear entrance to the garage building off Wilson. Walk to restaurants, galleries, breweries, shops, events, and the everyday amenities of this mountain valley town, with the Nantahala and surrounding outdoor recreation minutes away.The centerpiece is the 1905 main residence, recently renovated while retaining its historic character. It offers three bedrooms, one-and-a-half baths, and three formal rooms suited to entertaining or creative work. The kitchen was deliberately configured for cooking demonstrations and gatherings: a large island, full-sash windows, and French doors that open the space to light and the grounds. The result is a gracious, functional home that feels both period and fully livable. Complementing the main house is the garage complex, which consists of a large two car garage and expansive storage, an art studio and two two studio apartments. Additionally, there is a separate house, built in 1910, which has been newly remodeled as a triplex. Together the structures create a self-contained compound with flexible living, working, and guest capacity. An artist or maker can claim the studio and main residence while the additional units generate income; alternatively, the entire property can be operated as short-term rentals, a bed-and-breakfast, or a hybrid of private quarters and hospitality. The private Wilson Street access and garage building further support multi-unit or guest use without compromising the Main Street presence. Grounds of this scale are uncommon in the downtown core. The acreage provides room for gardens, outdoor gathering, parking, and future improvements while remaining fully walkable to town life. The combination of 1905 architecture, recent renovations, dedicated studio space, and multiple independent living units positions the property for a primary residence with income, a creative campus, or a hospitality venture--the layout supports all three. Ideal for those seeking both lifestyle and optionality in a walkable Western North Carolina mountain town.


 

Interior Features

Bedrooms

Master Bed LevelNon Primary Living Area
Total Bedrooms9

Bathrooms

Half Baths1
Total Baths8

Other Interior Features

SmokingYNNo
Air Conditioning Y/NYes
Attic FeaturesOther
BasementCrawl Space
Basement (Y/N)No
Fireplace Y/NYes
FlooringWood
Heating Y/NYes
Interior AmenitiesSee Remarks
Laundry FeaturesLaundry Room
Living Area Range2,400 sqft
Total Stories2
Water HeaterElectric

Other Rooms

Entry Level1
Room TypeLiving Room, Library, Dining Room, Dining Area, Bathroom 1, Bedroom 1, Bedroom 2, Bedroom 3, Laundry, Bathroom 2, Studio, Bathroom 3, Bathroom 4, Bedroom 5, Bedroom 6, Bedroom 7, Bathroom 5

General

Attached Garage No
Carport Spaces0.0
Carport Y/NNo
CityAndrews
Construction MaterialsWood Siding, Wood Frame
CoolingOther, Central Air, Ceiling Fan(s)
CountyCherokee
DirectionsComing from Murphy on Hwy 19, 74, 129 turn onto Main Street. Property will be on the left. Please do not use 837 Main Street driveway - it is very narrow.
Elementary SchoolAndrews
Full Baths7
Garage Spaces2.0
Garage Y/NYes
HOANo
HeatingOther, Electric, Heat Pump
High SchoolAndrews
Home Warranty Y/NNo
In City Limits? (Y/N)Yes
IslandOrMainlandMainland
Land Lease Y/NNo
Lease Considered Y/NNo
Legal DescriptionHOLDER 1159/527 1316/336 1334/414 &FR BABCOK-PAHULES 1315/399
LevelsTwo
Living Area2,578 sqft
Living Area Units0 sqft
Lot Size Square Feet111078.0
Lot Size UnitsAcres
Middle/Junior High SchoolAndrews
New ConstructionNo
Operating Expense0.0
Parcel Number555,616,823,884,000
Patio/Porch FeaturesDeck, Balcony, Front Porch
PossessionClose Of Escrow, At Closing
Property Attached Y/NNo
Property ConditionCompleted
Property SubtypeSingle Family Residence
Property TypeResidential
RoofComposition
Standard StatusActive
StatusActive
Structure TypeWood Frame, Stick Built
Subdivision NameNot In Subdivision
Tax Year2025
Total Rooms23
UtilitiesSewer Connected, Underground Utilities, Starlink
ViewNone
Year Built1905
ZoningCB

Exterior

Building Area Total2,578 sqft
Crops Included Y/NNo
Exterior FinishWood Siding
FencingWood, Fenced
Foundation DetailsCrawl Space
Frontage TypeSee Remarks
Horse Y/NNo
Lot DimensionsIRR
Lot FeaturesLevel, Cleared, Landscaped
Lot Size Acres2.55
Lot Size Area2 sqft
Parking FeaturesAdditional Parking, Gravel, Off Street, On Site, Garage
Road Frontage TypeCity Street, State Road
SpaNo
Total Parking2.0
Water SourcePublic
Waterfront Y/NNo

Additional Details

Price History

Schools 

Elementary School Andrews Elementary School
Middle School Andrews Middle School
High School Andrews High School

  

Similar Properties

$2,220,000

9 Beds 7 / 1 Full / Half Baths 2,578 SQFT 2.55 Acres
Type: Single Family

837 & 789 Main Street
Andrews, NC 28901

MLS#: 100608625
Brandyn Reagan
Brandyn Reagan
Bay Street Realty Group
Sales Associate
Phone: 912.335.9150
Office: 912.233.6000